Thar ROXX vs Jimny 5-Door: Which Off-Road SUV You Can Buy?

Thar Roxx 5-Door vs Jimny 5-Door: A Comprehensive Comparison

When it comes to off-road vehicles, the Mahindra Thar and the Maruti Suzuki Jimny have long been contenders, each with its dedicated fan base. While some may consider this comparison impractical due to their size differences, many enthusiasts are eager to see how these two 5-door off-roaders stack up against each other. We Compare the Mahindra Thar Roxx and the Jimny across various parameters, including price, features, driving dynamics, and interior space. Let’s dive in!

Price and Versions

Starting with the price, the Mahindra Thar Roxx is priced at ₹12,75,000 ex-showroom for the base version, while the Jimny offers a more affordable option with discounts, making the price gap significant between the two vehicles. This price difference is a key consideration for buyers balancing their budget with features.

The Thar Roxx offers multiple configurations, including petrol, diesel, manual, and automatic options. On the other hand, the Jimny features a 1.5-liter naturally aspirated petrol engine paired with a 4-speed automatic transmission. While the Thar Roxx offers more powertrain options, the Jimny's simplicity and compactness appeal to urban users and off-roaders alike.

Size and Road Presence

In terms of size, the Thar is undeniably bigger and more imposing on the road. Its larger dimensions give it a commanding presence, which makes it an appealing choice for those who prefer a rugged and bold look. At 6 feet tall, the Thar fits better for taller drivers, offering more headroom and legroom compared to the smaller Jimny. The Jimny, on the other hand, is smaller and more compact, which can be an advantage in tight urban environments or on narrow mountain roads. However, this smaller size can feel overshadowed by the bulkier Thar in terms of road presence.

Driving Dynamics and Comfort

When it comes to driving, both vehicles cater to different types of users. The Jimny, with its lighter frame and compact dimensions, is more nimble in tight spaces. Its suspension is excellent at absorbing road imperfections, making it a comfortable ride on uneven surfaces. However, despite its smaller size, it doesn’t have the tight turning radius you might expect, especially when compared to the Thar Roxx.

The Thar Roxx, with its bigger frame and more powerful engines, offers superior off-road performance. It comes with both diesel and petrol engines, offering better torque and overall power, making it an excellent choice for highway cruising and off-road adventures. In terms of comfort, the Thar Roxx is more spacious, with a higher seating position and a bigger panoramic sunroof, providing a more premium feel to the cabin.

Interior Features and Space

The Thar Roxx takes the lead in terms of interior space and features. It offers a larger cabin with more legroom, headroom, and storage spaces. The 19-inch wheels and elevated ride height further enhance the Thar's dominance over the Jimny. The Thar also spoils its occupants with premium features such as a bigger touchscreen infotainment system, powered driver’s seat, and ventilated seats. These added luxuries make the Thar a more feature-packed vehicle.

While the Jimny has a charming retro feel, with its twin-pod speedometer and minimalist dashboard, it falls short in terms of practical storage. It lacks cupholders, and rear charging outlets, and has a smaller boot, making it less practical for long road trips or family use.

Off-Road Capabilities

Both vehicles excel in off-road performance, but they have their own strengths. The Jimny’s lightweight design and superior suspension make it excellent for rugged terrains, especially in mountainous regions. The compact size allows for better maneuverability in tight off-road situations. However, it lacks the power and torque that the Thar Roxx offers, which becomes evident during high-speed highway cruising or when tackling tough off-road trails. The Thar Roxx, with its multiple engine options and 4x4 capabilities, outshines the Jimny when it comes to serious off-roading. Its larger size, better ground clearance, and more powerful engine options make it a better choice for those who need an all-rounder vehicle capable of handling urban environments, highways, and tough off-road terrains.

Fuel Efficiency and Long-Term Ownership

When it comes to fuel efficiency, the Jimny has the upper hand, especially in urban driving conditions. It offers better mileage compared to the Thar Roxx, which is powered by more fuel-hungry engines. For long-term ownership, the Jimny may also offer lower maintenance costs, making it a more affordable option for those looking for a reliable and economical vehicle.

Conclusion: Thar Roxx or Jimny?

Choosing between the Mahindra Thar Roxx and the Maruti Suzuki Jimny boils down to personal preference and intended use. If you’re looking for a powerful, spacious, and feature-packed vehicle that commands road presence, the Thar Roxx is the clear winner. Its superior off-road capabilities, bigger engine options, and luxurious features make it ideal for those who want an all-purpose vehicle.

However, if you prefer a compact, nimble, and more economical off-roader that performs well in tight urban spaces or on mountain roads, the Jimny is a solid choice. Its retro design, fuel efficiency, and lower price point make it an attractive option for those who prioritize practicality and simplicity oversize and power.

In the end, it’s a battle of heart vs. mind whether you go for the rugged power of the Thar Roxx or the practical charm of the Jimny, both vehicles have their unique strengths to offer.