- CarGraze
- Dec 02, 2024
- Car Info
Comparing EV Heavyweights: Tata Curve EV vs Mahindra BE 6e
In the world of electric vehicles (EVs), competition is heating up with every new release. Today, let’s dive into a detailed yet friendly comparison between two popular contenders: the Tata Curve EV and Mahindra BE 6e. Whether you're an EV enthusiast or planning your first electric purchase, this conversation-style guide will help you decide.
Price and Variants
The Tata Curve EV comes in at an ex-showroom price of ₹19.25 lakh for its mid-range variant. On the other hand, the Mahindra BE 6e starts at ₹18.90 lakh, but here's the catch: this price doesn’t include the charger installation, which will set you back extra bucks. Mahindra offers a basic portable charging gun but no wall-box charger. This adds a layer of costs and planning that Tata users might not face upfront.
Battery, Range, and Performance
Battery and Charging
The Curve EV is equipped with a 55 kWh battery, while the Mahindra BE 6e sports a slightly larger 59 kWh pack. This may seem like a small difference, but it translates into real-world benefits. The Mahindra BE 6e offers an MIDC-certified range of 556 km, compared to the Curve EV's 502 km.
Charging speeds also differ slightly. For a quick 20-80% top-up, Mahindra recommends a 140 kW DC fast charger, which is rare in India. Using regular home chargers, both cars take around 8-9 hours to fully charge, keeping them evenly matched in this department.
Performance Stats
Performance lovers, rejoice! The Mahindra BE 6e takes the lead with its powerful 231 bhp motor and a 0-100 km/h sprint in just 6.7 seconds. Tata Curve EV, with its 167 bhp motor, follows closely, achieving 0-100 km/h in 8.6 seconds. If speed and thrill are what you crave, the B6 edges ahead.
Interior Space and Comfort
Boot Space
Mahindra compromises on boot space due to its longer wheelbase, offering 455 litres, while Tata Curve EV boasts a spacious 500 litres. For practical, everyday use, the Tata Curve EV might better suit families or frequent travellers.
Seating Comfort
While Tata’s cabin design is sleek, Mahindra excels in providing ample legroom. However, the sloping roofline of the B6 slightly affects headroom. Curve EV offers decent space, but taller passengers may find the rear less accommodating.
Tech and Features
Warranty
Tata Curve EV provides a standard 8-year or 1.6 lakh km warranty for its battery. Meanwhile, Mahindra goes the extra mile with a lifetime warranty on the battery, although a cap of 2 lakh km applies to second owners.
Suspension and Ride Quality
Mahindra BE 6e features semi-active suspension and five-link rear suspension, ensuring a smoother and more stable ride, even at high speeds of 202 km/h. Tata Curve EV, while capable, doesn’t match the engineering finesse of the B6 in this area.
Entertainment and Displays
For tech lovers, the Mahindra BE 6e impresses with dual 12.3-inch screens, while the Tata Curve EV offers a slightly smaller 10.25-inch display in its comparable variant. Both cars support modern essentials like Android Auto, Apple CarPlay, and OTA updates.
Styling and Design
Exterior Appeal
The Mahindra BE 6e steals the show with its aggressive, sporty looks inspired by futuristic cyber designs. Tata Curve EV also has a modern aesthetic but doesn’t quite match the boldness of the B6.
Driving Dynamics
The rear-wheel-drive setup of the Mahindra BE 6e enhances handling and performance. In contrast, the Tata Curve EV features a front-wheel-drive layout, which is less thrilling but sufficient for daily city commutes.
Final Thoughts: Which One Should You Choose?
The Mahindra BE 6e stands out for its superior acceleration, futuristic features, and engineering marvels like semi-active suspension and brake-by-wire technology. It is the car for those who value performance and luxury, even if it comes at a slightly higher cost.
The Tata Curve EV, on the other hand, appeals to budget-conscious buyers looking for a reliable EV with decent features and a more practical design.
So, what’s your pick? Are you ready to splurge on the dynamic Mahindra BE 6e, or does the Tata Curve EV’s practicality sway your decision? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below.
Comments