Maruti Suzuki Brezza CNG vs Tata Nexon CNG: Detailed Review and Verdict

Tata Nexon CNG vs. Maruti Brezza CNG: In-Depth Comparison Review

Choosing between the Tata Nexon CNG and Maruti Brezza CNG can be tricky, as both models offer unique features suited to different needs. This article presents a detailed comparison of these two popular CNG SUVs, focusing on key performance aspects like design, comfort, features, driving dynamics, and value for money.

Exterior Design and Build Quality

Both cars offer robust designs, but the paint quality sets them apart. The Nexon has a higher paint thickness of 278 microns, giving it a more premium feel, compared to Brezza’s 239.5 microns.

Headlight Comparison:

• Nexon: Better spread but less intense beam.
• Brezza: Superior throw and intensity, better for night driving.

In terms of wheels, both feature 16-inch tyres, but the Brezza's high-end CNG model is limited to the ZXI variant, offering alloy wheels but no dual-tone option. Meanwhile, Nexon’s frameless wipers add a premium touch compared to Brezza’s conventional ones.

Interior Comfort and Features

The Nexon takes the lead in premium features, offering a panoramic sunroof, ventilated seats, and leather upholstery, which are unavailable in Brezza's CNG variant. Additionally, Nexon provides a 360-degree camera, while the Brezza sticks to a regular reverse camera unless it’s the petrol version.

Boot Space:

• Nexon: 321 litres.
• Brezza: Limited space, fitting fewer bags comfortably.

Both models offer decent cabin storage, but the Nexon boasts a larger glove box, enhancing practicality. Charging options are generous in both vehicles, with USB, Type-C, and 12V sockets available for front and rear passengers.

Driving Experience: Performance and Dynamics

When it comes to performance, the Nexon sets a new benchmark as India's first turbo CNG SUV. Its 1.2-litre turbo petrol engine ensures smooth pickup and quick overtakes. On the other hand, Brezza’s 1.5-litre non-turbo engine provides a more linear power delivery, making it ideal for city commutes.

Gearbox:

• Nexon: 6-speed manual.
• Brezza: 5-speed manual.

The Nexon has a lighter clutch but longer, slightly notchy gear shifts, while the Brezza offers smoother shifts, perfect for traffic conditions. However, Brezza struggles beyond 80 km/h, making highway overtaking challenging compared to the Nexon’s more confident high-speed performance.

Ride Quality and Comfort

Both SUVs excel in ride quality, with improved suspension tuning for their CNG variants. The Nexon offers a ground clearance of 208mm, slightly higher than Brezza’s 200mm. Rear seat comfort is also well-handled in both vehicles, comfortably seating three passengers in the back.

Noise and Vibration Levels (NVH):

• At 60 km/h, Nexon records 65.6 dB compared to Brezza’s 67.3 dB.
• Nexon’s engine noise is more noticeable, being a 3-cylinder setup, despite Tata’s efforts to improve insulation.

Performance Metrics and Verdict

Acceleration (0-100 km/h):

• Nexon: 14.44 seconds.
• Brezza: 15.24 seconds.

City Overtaking Time (40-80 km/h):

• Nexon: 2.96 seconds.
• Brezza: 3.17 seconds.

The Nexon excels in hill climbs, thanks to its turbo engine, but the Brezza performs well under full passenger load, albeit with less power on tap.

Value for Money and Resale

Tata Nexon provides a superior feature set, making it an attractive option for those seeking modern amenities. Its turbo engine, sunroof, and added boot space make it a well-rounded package. However, the Maruti Brezza offers better fuel efficiency and reliability, with Maruti’s extensive service network being a major advantage.

While Nexon enjoys a strong resale value, Brezza’s reliability gives it an edge in terms of long-term ownership. Tata’s vehicles have improved mechanically, but Nexon owners might encounter minor software glitches, which Maruti avoids with its simpler electronics.

Final Verdict

Both Nexon CNG and Brezza CNG serve different needs. If you prioritize performance, features, and premium comfort, the Tata Nexon is the clear winner. However, if you value fuel efficiency, reliability, and ease of driving, especially in city conditions, the Maruti Brezza is an excellent choice.

Ultimately, your decision should align with your driving preferences. Do you prefer turbocharged performance with premium features, or is long-term reliability with a simple, easy-to-drive setup more appealing to you? Either way, both models stand out in the competitive CNG SUV market, ensuring you won’t go wrong with either choice.